Pineapple Butter Cake Recipe – Chef Dennis

by 157 Comments

pineapple butter cake with whipped cream sitting on a white plate with strawberry on a brown background

This super moist and buttery pineapple cake is sure to make your family and friends very happy.  Once you see how easy it is to create this delicious cake you'll be making it all the time!

Total Time: 50 minutes
Jump to RecipePrint Recipe
Share
Tweet
Pin
Yum
+1
Share
405 Shares

How to make a sinfully delicious and rich Pineapple Butter Cake

One of my go-to cakes for the fall is an Italian apple cake so I thought I would adapt the recipe and turn it into a Pineapple Butter Cake. This cake is basically a very light butter cake batter that surrounds the tasty morsels of pineapple sautéed in butter…….sigh. In this case Butter = Love!

2 pictures of pineapple butter cake on a brown background

I think that’s actually in the foodie dictionary somewhere (well it should be if it’s not!)

My wife loves pineapple, but like anything else, she only eats a little bit of it, and then I’m stuck with what’s ever left…..sigh. That’s why our neighbors greet me drooling when I knock on their doors, they know it’s time for dessert! But with fresh cut pineapple I feel a little strange walking it over, so I decided to make a cake with what I had left.

pineapple butter cake with whipped cream sitting on a white plate with strawberry on a brown background
I had made a pineapple upside down cake earlier in the year, and we all know you can’t repost something quite that soon, even if it was delicious!

My neighbors even know how it works now, I was greeted last week with that chocolate cake was incredible, but you probably won’t make it again will you….lol….we must move forward, new recipes, new posts, new frontiers!

Well sometimes we just change things up a bit, but it is rare that I make anything twice in the dessert arena (although my Tiramisu has just moved to the front of the list!).

This cake is easy to make and is sure to please your family or guests if my wife liked coconut I may have added some a little coconut to the batter! Can anyone say Pina Colada? Tropical beaches, boat drinks, a little Jimmy Buffet on the radio….sigh, it just doesn’t get better than that!!! But there I go again getting off topic…….let’s get back to the pineapple cake. I hope you enjoy it.

pineapple butter cake with whipped cream sitting on a white plate with strawberry on a brown background

If you’ve tried my pineapple butter cake recipe or any other recipe on askchefdennis.com please don’t forget to rate the recipe and let me know where you found it in the comments below, I love hearing from you! You can also FOLLOW ME  on Instagram @chefdenniseats and @chefdennistravels,  Twitter and Facebook.

4.85 from 26 votes
Print
Pineapple Butter Cake

This super moist and buttery pineapple cake is sure to make your family and friends very happy.  Once you see how easy it is to create this delicious cake you'll be making it all the time!

Author: Chef Dennis Littley
Nutrition Facts
Pineapple Butter Cake
Amount Per Serving
Calories 274 Calories from Fat 108
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 12g 18%
Saturated Fat 7g 35%
Cholesterol 71mg 24%
Sodium 163mg 7%
Potassium 102mg 3%
Total Carbohydrates 38g 13%
Sugars 29g
Protein 2g 4%
Vitamin A 8.8%
Vitamin C 24.1%
Calcium 3%
Iron 4.6%
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: American
Prep Time: 15 mins
Cook Time: 35 mins
Total Time: 50 mins
Servings: 8
Calories: 274 kcal
pineapple butter cake with whipped cream sitting on a white plate with strawberry on a brown background
Ingredients
  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter 120 g
  • 2 cups chopped pineapple 300 g
  • 2/3 cup all purpose flour 80 g
  • 1/2 tsp baking powder 2.5 g
  • 1/2 tsp salt 2.5 g
  • 2 whole eggs plus 1 egg yolk
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract 5 ml
  • 1 cup granulated sugar 200 g
  • 1/2 tsp grated lemon zest 2.5 g
  • Confectioners sugar to dust
Instructions
  1. Preheat oven to 350 F (177 C),
  2. Butter a 9” round cake pan

  3. In a large frying pan over low heat, melt the butter, reserve 6 tbs (90 g) for later. Add the pineapple and cook for about 10 minutes.  **do not use any of the juice from the pan only the pineapple

  4. In a small bowl mix together flour, salt and baking powder.
  5. In a large bowl beat the whole eggs and egg yolks until blended.
  6. Add the reserved melted butter, sugar, vanilla and lemon zest.
  7. Stir in flour and pineapple.
  8. Spoon into prepared pan, smoothing the top.
  9. Bake until cake is browned, 30-35 minutes.
  10. Transfer to a wire rack to cool in pan for 5 minutes. Invert cake onto plate to remove the pan and then invert again and return to rack to cool completely.
  11. Before serving
  12. Dust with confectioners sugar
Share
Tweet
Pin
Yum
+1
Share
405 Shares

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. I can't wait to make this cake for my husband! He loves pineapple upside down cake, but this looks much better. I may add coconut, as you suggested too. Thank you for the blogging info. I still haven't had the time to figure out Foodbuzz…

    Reply

    • I just made the cake last night and added coconut but add the coconut to flour first to coat it and then add to wet ingredients. IT WAS DELICIOUS!!!

      Reply

  2. Well, since I've recently added a pineapple cake to my baking repertoire, I can imagine how wonderful yours tastes. Pineapple chunks add so much freshness to a cake that it actually makes sense to add it. I love how moist yours looks and the sunshine-y color of the cake is irresistible! Well done!

    Reply

  3. Oh, Dennis!!! I'm closing my eyes and dreaming of swaying palms, warm azure oceans and sandy beaches. Yes, the Piña Colada is in my hand and the "guy" (the one who delivers anything you want, even on the beach) is bringing this cake.
    Thanks for the ray of sunshine into my not so tropical week!!

    Reply

  4. Butter cake has to be my favorite cake! Something about it is irresistible to me! And this one – with the pineapple – is just to die for! It looks so fresh, moist and vibrant! I love it! Thank you for sharing 🙂 And as always, thank you for the blogging tips!

    Reply

  5. Ooh, that cake looks so good! You know, I've never had any sort of pineapple cake- including pineapple upside down cake- I think that's something I should rectify soon. Love the coconut idea as well!

    Reply

  9. I am reading this on my sons' computer and I have Blue Coat blocking all photos (don't ask), so simply judging by your recipe and winning words, I am guessing that pineapple cake is pretty yummy. I will come back tomorrow for a peek at the photos.

    I wish Foodbuzz weren't so big because they seem to be the powerhouse site for foodies to gather, but I don't feel like we connect as much there as we do on individual blogs. I don't know if I conveyed that properly, but there is something missing at Fbz.

    I learn something each Wednesday, so thanks for doing the Ask Chef Dennis feature.

    Reply

  10. Oh Chef! I luv everything about this cake, including it's title. What's not to like about "pineapple", "butter", and "cake" Looks like it has a delicate texture…my kinda cake 😉

    Reply

  11. This cake looks beautiful and so yummy! I wish I had some pineapple to make it tomorrow 🙂 guess I'll need to go to the store!

    Love the post and links! Always something new to learn here 😀

    Reply

  13. hey uhh….could you dial back the useful information in one post please? I can't keep up with everything. I feel like 'm in my college honors classes again…they are WAY better than the other classes, but man they move quick. My to do list gets bigger every time I read you and as you know…I've only been reading you for one day! 🙂

    Thanks for the tips. Of all the online communities I've been a part of, I find the foodie community to be the most helpful and kind, I am really lovin' this so far.

    Reply

  14. Chef Dennis…I am going to try this out…looks delish ! Sometimes I just cant think what to do with it other than cooking them in fish curry 🙂 And thank you so much for taking the trouble explaining again and again about foodbuzz and the buzzes stuff :p

    I haven't got the time to explore out the food porn sites yet but will do so as soon as work pressure is over next week 🙂 Dead tired after work 🙁

    Have a nice day Chef 🙂

    Cheers,
    Elin

    Reply

  15. great looking cake!
    I find your info so useful! Why don't you start a foodbuzz kind of site yourself? :))

    Reply

  17. What a gorgeous, delicious-sounding cake! Love me some pineapple!

    Thanks for another useful round of Ask Dennis…I'm not good at tagging my posts, but you've convinced me!

    Have a great day, Dennis!

    Reply

  20. Butter = love So so true!! Another great post. I'm glad you plugged Baking is Hot. I have been featured there many times and I love the site. It is refreshing to see some recipes that don't get deatured on other foodporn sites. I'm a big fan of Baking is Hot! 🙂

    Reply

  21. Chef,
    Thanks for the shout out! We still
    need a few more bakers!

    This pineapple butter cake is divine. This cakes transports me to the sunny, warm Caribbean beaches. After the weather we're having, snow,sleet and rain, I need that beautiful cake now.

    Reply

  22. Pineapple cake was always an Easter staple at our house growing up.

    I loved the food pic in a rut post. I read it a few days ago and it makes me want to spread out my pics and see what has changed and how I've moved forward.

    Thanks for the tips on subscribers – I know I haven't gotten back to your email and Im sorry. The boss is away on vacation so the Im the captain this week…. and dog sitting… and getting ready for Easter… lol. excuses excuses.

    I love Baking is Hot! Thanks for the new suggestions to check out!

    Reply

  23. Wow, this cake looks amazing! I love anything pineapple and can't wait to make it! I love Jimmy Buffett too and this cake sounds like his music in a bite!

    Reply

  24. I'm the only one in our household who enjoys pineapple but this sounds incredible and looks so moist. Yummy!

    Reply

  25. Dennis I am drooling!! I have now gone almost 40 days with absolutely NO desserts or sweets and this has my eye popping out of my head! YUM YUM YUM!!

    and yum! haha

    Thanks for all the information on your Ask Dennis section. I am participating in Becky's bake sale… I am so excited!

    Reply

  26. So first your blog tempted me with all the yummies and beautiful photos and stories of the Mount. Now you've gone and added all these tips and links. You sure know how to keep us coming back. Your blog is now a daily read for me – even to re-read older posts. Always something new is found. Thanks so much!

    Reply

  27. First the cake look so delicious that if I didn't have one planned for Easter I'd probably make this one.

    Second, thank you for all the blogging tips and information as well as blogs to visit – love it.

    Finally, love to visit you! Have a great Easter!

    Reply

  29. My favorite post of the week, thanks!

    The apple cake looks delicious. I always have to twist my husbands arm though about cake. He LOVES pie.

    Reply

  30. Tempting and yummy cake! Thanks for hosting "Ask Chef Dennis" and sharing those useful tips. Have a great day!

    Reply

  32. The presentation alone is making me drool… the cake is just incredible!

    And thank you for your blogging tips… they are greatly appreciated! Have a wonderful rest of the week!

    Reply

  33. Yum… I love pineapple and wish I was one of your neighbors! Great idea for the addition of coconut and with a bit of liquor, possibly that Pina Colada will come true!

    Reply

  34. I love the brown background with your pineapple cake. It looks so beautiful and what fantastically piped whip cream! Those shots could be the cover of a book. Have a beautiful Wednesday Chef Dennis!

    Reply

  35. Your willingness to constantly share your knowledge is so appreciated. Oh, and your pineapple cake looks incredible!

    Reply

  36. Wow – beautiful picture! The pineapple butter cake looks amazing.

    And thank you for all the helpful information about foodbuzz. I really don't know what I am doing on there so it was extremely helpful for me to read, thank you!

    Reply

  38. Three magic words – pineapple, butter, and cake. As you can imagine I always seem to have pineapple at my house. I am really looking forward to putting it to good use and trying this cake.

    Reply

  39. This is the BEST looking pineapple cake. I swoon for anything buttery! And loving your 'Ask Dennis" section. The blogging questions/answers are helpful. 🙂

    Reply

  40. Those are some lucky neighbors. I love pineapple cakes, with fresh pineapple now that's heaven. Looks really yummy Dennis. Have a great week.

    Reply

  41. I must find neighbors who bake like you. The photos make me want to dig in. Pineapple or apple – really, I'm not fussy.

    Reply

  42. Oh man, you just combined a few of my favorite things: butter + cake + seasonal delights! Loveeee the addition of the pineapple! (and thanks, as always for sharing your wisdom!)

    Reply

  43. Lovely cake. I'll be rocking the Pina Colada version, myself 🙂 Thanks again for all the awesome (and valuable) information!

    Reply

  44. I love this cake! I think it was the apple one you made for the guest post for me! It is a wonderful (and versatile) cake.

    Reply

  45. Chef what an incredible cake. I will be making this the next time we have guests over.
    🙂 Mandy

    Reply

  46. congrats on the top 9! woohoo!
    lovely pictures and this is another cake recipe i look forward to trying…

    Reply

  47. Congrats on the the Top 9 today! This cake sounds fabulous. Pineapple is my favorite fruit, so I love any excuse to bake with it. Can't wait to try this!

    Reply

  48. Well that's nice! you do all this great posting for other people and then you are rewarded with #1 in the top 9 – a testimony in Karma.

    Thank you for your willingness to help those who want to improve. I haven't been here long, but your information has helped me very much.

    Reply

  49. You won't believe me, but I was actually thinking about pineapple cake just yesterday – thanks for the recipe! Also thanks for the blogging and food buzz tips. I hadn't been posting under 2 categories – will look into that pronto.

    [Btw, you have a typo in your first paragraph. You wrote 'apples' instead of 'pineapples'. Normally I wouldn't nitpick but that might be confusing. :-)]

    Reply

  51. Hi Ruby

    it wasn't a typo, thanks, I was just stating that the Italian apple cake (which is a butter cake) was a favorite in the fall, but since my wife likes pineapple I was making something else. Sorry if it was confusing.

    Dennis

    Reply

  52. Chef Dennis, I always love stopping by your site! First of all I live in Florida and your pineapple butter cake just made me feel "tropica" for the first time all week! You are always so informative as well … thanks!

    Reply

  53. Perfect timing with this one, I'm still finalizing my Easter menu. I was eyeing that tiramisu too and now I might have to make both. Great advice as always. Hoping you and Mrs. D have a wonderful Easter.
    -Gina-

    Reply

  54. Thanks so much for this post, Chef Dennis!

    Your cake looks fabulous and I really appreciated your tips, especially the one about Google Feedburner.

    Congrats on the Top 9 today – well deserved!!

    Reply

  56. Congrats on Top 9, I do have half a pineapple in my fridge and this sounds like a perfect cake to bake for this weekend! So enticing!

    Reply

  57. Fabby photos – you seem to be going from strength to strength! You blog is a wonderful mine of information and inspiration to all.

    Top 9 again I see. Well done ! For me that's but a dream. My photography needs a serious butt kick before that would ever happen ;-P

    Reply

  58. I love fresh pineapple and I couldn't imagine anything better than this scrumptious looking cake! In fact, I'm going to make it today, and there won't be any left for the neighbors! 🙂 Thanks for another great recipe!

    Reply

  59. You had me at Pina Colada! I can't wait to try this recipe. I have some coconut gelato in the freezer that would be perfect with it.

    Reply

  66. Hi I just joined your site, The pineapple cake looks wonderful. I made a cake posted on my site with raspberries its easy and tasty. Yesterday I hooked up on food buzz, have excepted a lot of friends, haven't done anything with it yet. Thanks for the posting about food buzz Thanks for following me. I just started this but am not a blogger. I only post what I have made and if I like it. Keep cooking Andi

    Reply

  68. Dennis,

    That is one beautiful pineapple cake! I'm a huge butter fan as well. It makes me wish I was your neighbor. 🙂 I guess I'll just have to whip up one of my own. Thanks for the links to the new food porn sites. I'll definitely check them out!

    Reply

  70. my husband doesn't like pineapple (or coconut…but he does like Jimmy Buffet haha) – how I wish I was your neighbor!!! Lucky for me I know a few other pineapple fans so I can have an excuse to try this awesome cake….

    you cracked me up about your buzz starting to fade (like the sixties)…sighhhh….you are hilarious.

    Reply

  72. That looks delicious! I love pineapple but the fresh ones always gives my tongue a fuzzy feel after. Now cooking it this way might just work for me! I guess I could also substitute with the canned ones? Oh, btw, I like square pics 😀 Congrats on getting top9.

    Reply

  74. Thanks for sharing your wealth of knowledge, as always! Your openness and willingness to listen and share is an asset to us all.

    (And I really wish I were your neighbour!)

    Reply

  75. Dennis, this cake sounds awesome! I am loving how there is pinapple throughout the batter and not just on top! What a great way to use up the pinapple that you did have left ;)! I am sure your wife loved it! This cake seems like it would be perfect on an Easter table! Hope you have a wonderful holiday weekend :)!

    Reply

  76. Any cake with butter in the name HAS to be good. LOVE the photograph, I nearly bit my screen! Fortunately my nose got in the way before I could do any damage.

    Thinking of you my friend. I know I haven't been around much but I am still here admiring your posts and photographs!

    Reply

  78. I made this for Easter dessert. Saw it on Foodbuzz. I have to eat gluten-free and recipes that have less flour tend to work better. So I substituted my GF flour blend and with just the 2/3 c flour it came out wonderfully. My hubby had two pieces! It would be good for breakfast too!

    Reply

  79. Hi Dennis, thank you for the info on Feedburner analytics. I never knew that it was possible to see how many people subscribe to my feed 🙂

    Reply

  81. I have made your original apple cake, and I know that it is fantastic! I absolutely love the idea of making it with pineapple! Thanks for the great idea. Your photos, especially the second one, makes me want a piece right now!

    Reply

  82. Dennis, you made me giggle re: your 60’s buzz analogy! Although I can’t relate to that, I CAN “totally” relate to your “bodacious” pineapple cake. (To coin a little 90’s vernacular…) 🙂 I also think it’s wonderful that you shared with your neighbors… to me, that’s one of the pleasures of baking and cooking.

    Reply

  83. Same issue here with my husband. he gets the taste for something and 3/4 is left and I have to figuere out how to use it in my cooking.

    chef you have out dnne yourself again, your cake looks so delectable and moist, I d finnish it in 5 mins.

    Thanks for the tips and links i your post. In feedburner u can only see the email subscribers right? not the others. I l check out some of the other new pages and psots u mentioned.

    I wish u a lovely sunny weekend ahead!

    Reply

  84. It is in the oven cooking now! My question is that you said reserve 6 tbs for later. Later for in the recipe, I didn’t find it or for later to use for whatever?
    I was a little confused with the description of inverting the cake. I get you invert onto the plate to remove the pan and then you say invert again and cool on rack. Back into the pan ( I wouldn’t think so) but onto another plate? That is what I think you mean??? Thanks! 5 mins. to go!

    Reply

      • So 6 TBS butter to cook the pineapple in but how much butter goes in the cake (step 6)? That is confusing me a bit.

        Reply

        • the recipe calls for a half a cup of butter in total which is 8 tablespoons. Melt all the butter then remove 6 tbs for the cake. Add the pineapple to the remaining butter and cook for about 10 minutes.

          Reply

    • My cake turned out WONDERFUL! Was never able to flip it out of the pan, but regardless I served it sliced from the pan. No big deal. Was wonderful with fresh homemade cream on top! My husband loved it!!!

      Reply

  85. I tried this recipe for already several times. It is quick, easy and wonderful!!!! Once I made it, when we had a call and learned about guests that are on their way. I managed to serve a fresh made and wonderful cake right from the oven, the minute tea and coffee were ready and fruits on the table.

    Reply

  86. Made this cake tonight and it was fabulous. So easy to make, and filled with flavor. Thanks for sharing.

    Reply

  87. Just made your cake. Is gorgeous – thanks very much. Will make it again on a rainy day in Cornwall (England)

    Reply

  89. So I posted whether the sugar was the correct amount.

    Just made it. Mine turned out like a pancake. Eggy, Dense and did not rise. Tastes good but too sweet. Ok so. Do you drain the juices after cooking the pineapple. Also is it plain flour or self raising.

    Could also do with more zest. If I can figure out my problem I would try again.

    Reply

    • I don’t know what to tell you on how it came out Hal, perhaps there was too much juice in your pineapple, mine did not have that much did you use fresh pineapple? It just plain all purpose flour. It’s not going to rise a lot, it is a dense cake because you’re using melted butter instead of softened butter, but as you can see by the picture of my finished cake it came out well.
      I would suggest not adding any juice from the pineapple, that may have been your problem

      Reply

  92. I am making this cake quite often, and both my family and friends love it. This is one of rare recipes where I don’t make any changes, as it is very good as is!! It is also quite quick and always turns out good!!! Thank you for this recipe!!! I’ve shared it with many friends, who love baking!!!

    Reply

  93. I made this last night and it was delicious. I added about 1/4 cup of coconut. It smelled so good I could barely wait for it to cool off before having a bite. Making again for a family gathering this weekend!

    Reply

  95. I just happened across this blog post yesterday as I was searching for a dessert for company and a way to use up my pineapple. I try to stick with the tried and true when baking for company, but I was desperate. I needed to comment because this is probably the easiest cake I have ever made and it was so good! It’s moist and is just sweet enough. I think I’ll try the same recipe with apples next time. This is one for the recipe box for sure!

    Reply

  96. Seems most everyone writes about “wanting to try it . . .” Doesn’t anyone comment AFTER making it? I would like to make this cake for a birthday celebration. Is the cake too moist to withstand two layers with frosting? That is – without sliding or sinking or being too sweet? I have the perfect frosting , , ,

    Reply

  97. I made this cake last night. I was a bit surprised at the small amount of flour, but I made it any way. I suggest that you wait 10 minutes before removing from the pan and then doing the flip/flop plate/wire rack move. Mine was not quite ready (OK, so it was me who was anxious), and it broke apart a little. That’s OK … I ate those parts to make sure they were good. Boy, were they!! Yummmmm; so juicy from the fresh pineapple1

    Reply

    • hi Dee

      This is definitely a cake that has to sit for a little while to set up , but oh so delicious and buttery! Glad to hear you enjoyed it and if you want to add a tablespoon or two more flour if you’re pineapple is extra juicy it might help bind it more.

      Reply

  98. I just made this cake this past weekend – IT IS DELICIOUS! also this is a perfect recipe -as in the cake was the right amount of moist etc. I actually poured the batter into cupcake pans and adjusted time. Perfect for work. Everyone loved them.

    Reply

  99. I did make this cake, and it tasted very good. However, my baking powder must have been too old, as the cake turned out to be a pancake. It didn’t rise. I’ll have to try this recipe again.

    Reply

  100. Dennis, OMG OMG this cake was delicious like terribly addiicting….we loved it. I added a whole pinneaple, so like 1/2 cup more than the recipe, it was outrageously delicious. will definitely be making this cake often.
    Thanks,

    Reply

  101. How would I need to change the baking time and temp to make cupcakes from this Pineapple Butter Cake?
    This looks delicious and judging by the comments, it is. I’d love to make this recipe for a group meeting tomorrow night and cupcakes are the preferred method of serving this group — easier to put out, faster to clean up, no cutting, no plates and no utensils needed.
    Any suggestions for what changes would need to be made?

    Reply

      • Excellent! Scrumptious! Very moist and delicious. I received many compliments but they really belong to you, Chef Dennis.
        I ran the pineapple quickly through the blender and then followed the recipe exactly. (Next time I will chop the pineapple into small chunks instead of blending.)
        The recipe made 12 cupcakes. I set the timer to check them after 18 minutes and sticking a toothpick into the center showed they were done.

        Reply

  102. This cake is so easy to make and so good! The best parts are you do not have to separate eggs and beat it or whip butter. I made so many time and each time come out perfect. Today I made one with apples. I can’t wait to taste it.

    Reply

    • thanks so much for your feedback Naomi, and I’m very happy to hear you enjoyed the cake recipe! Apple was the original way I made it and then pineapple, and blueberry! Its just such a lovely easy cake its hard not to fall in love with it!

      Reply

  103. Aldi often has pineapples on sale for 99 cents. Since there are only two of us, it is difficult to consume an entire pineapple quickly. This recipe is delicious and freezes well. I love pineapple upside down cake as well, but I think this recipe is more reliable with fresh pineapple.

    Reply

  104. Hi Chef.
    I am making your cake right now in my toaster oven I only had an 8 by 8 glass pan. I noticed the top was getting brown to fast so I tented with foil. Do I need to cook it longer since it is a smaller pan?

    Reply

  106. Thank you so much Chef Dennis! I made your pineapple cake exactly as specified in the recipe with the exception of using frozen (defrosted) pineapples as opposed to fresh ones, it was all I had on hand 🙁

    As tasty as it was, I know the flavors will be 100x better with fresh ones, so I will surely be making another one soon.
    One suggestion for the Pina Colada enthusiast… whip up some coconut milk whipped cream, it is a subtle addition to the already perfect cake. Happy baking! :))

    Reply

  107. Hey, I know this post is old and the odds of you responding are slim..but I just finished my batter…was i suppose to drain the pineapple after cooking? There was a ton of juice and it made the batter really thin…i m going to add more flour, but I’d still like to know for the future.
    Thanks!

    Reply

    • hi Jessica

      I’m sorry for not being clearer in the instructions, I have corrected them. You shouldn’t use any of the juice from the frying pan with the pineapple. Thats why we reserve most of the butter until later.

      Reply

  108. Really simple to make and so delicious! I will add coconut next time because I love it but it’s perfect as it is too.

    Reply

  110. A little story and context. It was my fiancee’s birthday yesterday. He loves coconut, so I WAS going to make him this really complicated recipe for coconut cake. However, after having a mini meltdown from not being able to find any coconuts (I eventually did find one, but that’s beside the point), I managed to calm myself and search for inspiration.

    That’s when I remembered that he LOVES pineapple. He even loves it on pizza! I considered an upside-down cake, but I wanted it to be more special and unique than that. So I searched to internet and came across this recipe. Long story short, I made this cake with a coconut glaze/icing, and now it’s his new favorite cake (pushing down key lime cake to 2nd place).

    Some notes on my experience:

    1) Pairing this with a coconut frosting or glaze is a good call if you like that sort of thing. If you want an actual frosting consistency, add the liquid to the powdered sugar a little at a time. Having too much liquid will give you a light glaze instead. If this happens, adding in some shredded coconut to it will thicken it up enough to spread (and give it an interesting look. My fiancee even preferred it this way to actual frosting, since having it as a glaze didn’t overpower the pineapple flavor.

    2) I did try to make my own coconut cream (for the frosting) with the coconut I eventually found. My takeaway from that is to just buy coconut milk and boil it down to a cream. It’s not worth the headache, and I still had to use imitation coconut flavor anyway.

    3) I messed with the recipe just a smidgen. Along with the mentioned ingredients, I added a little imitation coconut, the juice of half my lemon, and about a teaspoon or more of pineapple juice (I cut up a fresh pineapple and reserved two cups of chunks. I let the remainder sit in a container overnight and poured in the juice that collected on the bottom. next time, I may squeeze the remainder of the chunks for more juice).

    4) If you’re going to add extra liquids, make sure to add in more flour. I added a half cup or more flour to make up for my extra flavorings, and it still needed an extra 25 minutes in the oven to bake up. My advice would be to make the batter just as the recipe calls, study the batter’s consistency, and then add your flavorings. Then add in flour and baking powder slowly until your batter thickens up to the way it was again. Then bake up and test with a toothpick until it comes out with maybe a few crumbs, but not wet.

    5) Taking this out of the pan was a bit of an ordeal. May sure your cake is completely cool or almost completely cool before trying to remove it. The bottom of my cake stuck to the pan. Luckily, it wasn’t much and the top was just fine.

    6) This does make a thin cake, about an inch and a half. So if you want a layer cake, you’ll need to make about 1 batch per layer you want, as you won’t be able to cut this thing in half.

    Reply

  111. Hi Dennis,

    I made this cake a few hours ago, and it hardly rose. The finished cake is only about 3/4 in high. I also could not get it out of the pan. I will just cut it in the pan, and hope is is not too heavy. What could I have done wrong, as I followed the recipe without any alterations. Thanks

    Reply

  112. This was decious and easy to make. This pineapple butter cake will be added to my needed repatoir. It was a big hit with my family. I love how you get a fresh taste of pineapple in every bite. Thank you so much for this recipe.

    Reply

  113. Had a fresh pineapple that needed to be used so I made this cake this morning for Sunday brunch (to RAVE reviews)! I doubled the recipe and used a 9″ sprngform pan, baking for 55 minutes; perfection. So moist and simple, the pineapple shines. Tasted AMAZING paired with home-smoked bacon. Will definitely use this as my go-to potluck shareable!

    Reply

  114. How to make a non-baker look like a seasoned one. Give her an easy scrumptious, no fail recipe.
    I made this cake an hour ago and my family has devoured it, It’s completely gone!
    Because I read a lot of the comments I squeezed much of the juice our of the pineapple before putting it in the fry pan. My eggs are beautiful large eggs so I ended up adding more flour to the mix and in Entebbe Uganda it’s not easy to just pop out and pick up ingredients so I used brown sugar instead of white and it was still spectacular. This was a dry run for an event on Saturday where I’ll be serving it to 25 guests. A great big thank you Chef Dennis. I’m truly grateful in the land of juicy pineapples.

    Reply

  115. I made this cake yesterday. It did not raise as high as the one in the photo and wasn’t as cake-y … but it was very good. Probably a little moister than it was supposed to be because I didn’t fully drain the pineapple in the butter … got most of it but definitely not all. Also, I added a little extra lemon zest than called for and a heaping tablespoon of shredded, unsweetened coconut. The shreddy texture of the coconut was a nice addition. I served it with frozen vanilla yogurt. Pineapple is quite sweet, so next time I will probably reduce the sugar to 2/3 cup and I also will probably add 3/4 tsp of vanilla instead of the full teaspoon. But as it, the recipe is good … I’m just tweeking it to my own preferences. Next time I’ll do a better job draining the butter which will probably result in a cakier finish. Thanks so much!

    Reply

  116. Made this cake today. It was a little sweet for my taste. Oh, it is delicious though. I was wondering how much sugar could be removed without affecting the texture.

    Reply

    • hi Deborah

      you could try cutting it back by 1/3 of a cup to see how that works for you. It gets tricky when you start adjusting ingredients with baking, so I wouldn’t try more than that amount, otherwise, the entire recipe would have to be reworked.

      Reply

  117. Thank you for this recipe. I made this over the weekend…it was so delicious. I followed the directions and it came out wonderful. I’m now making for a potluck at work today and I am attempting to double the recipe and bake in a 9×12 pan…the presentation won’t be as nice but I’m sure it will taste delicious. Fingers crossed.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe for FREE and get every recipe delivered fresh!

Subscribe for FREE and get every recipe delivered fresh!

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates as well as every recipe for FREE. We promise to only send out emails when new recipes and content go live - so you are sure to never miss a delicious new post or video from Chef Dennis! 

Almost Finished! Please check your inbox for a confirmation email.

Share
Tweet
Pin
Yum
+1
405 Shares